What Should Your Lead Knee Do in the Backswing?

Coach Carolin
Coach Carolin
Jul 1, 2024 · Intermediate · Righty and lefty
Coach Carolin shows the lead knee wall drill in her hallway

Freewith this lesson

Carolin's Full Swing Cheat Sheet

Coach Carolin on YouTubeA new lesson every week. Millions of golfers follow Coach Carolin's lessons.
Subscribe

The short answer

Your lead knee can move a little, but it should never collapse in. When it collapses, your hips turn as far as your shoulders, you over-swing and you can't turn back to the target. Feel your lead knee push toward a wall so you coil instead of just turning.

Is this your problem?

  • Your swing gets too long and you over-swing
  • At impact your hips and shoulders are still square instead of turned toward the target
  • Your lead knee drops in toward the ball in the backswing

Coil versus turn

When the lead knee collapses, the hip follows. Now your hips and shoulders both face away from the target, your shoulder plane gets flat and your swing gets too long.

From there it's hard to turn back. You throw the club from the top, your hands overtake your body and your body stalls. Aim for about 90 degrees of shoulder turn and about half of that in your hips.

“create coil, not turn”

Coach Carolin, in the lesson at 5:11

The lead knee wall drill

Righty: stand with your left side next to the wall.
Lefty: stand with your right side next to the wall.
  1. Stand with your lead foot next to a wall.
  2. Turn back and feel your lead knee push toward the wall.
  3. Let the knee move a little as you rotate, but never let it collapse in.
  4. Check the top: hips turned about half as much as your shoulders, lead shoulder under your chin.
  5. Then turn toward the target, with your hands trailing your body.
This is a drill, so it exaggerates. Feel and real are not the same thing. A little lead knee movement in your real swing is fine.

How you know it's working

Your hips turn about half as much as your shoulders.
Your backswing gets shorter without trying.
You arrive at impact with your hips already turned toward the target.

Free: Full Swing Cheat Sheet

Carolin's key positions on one page, for the range.

Get it free

Key takeaways

Coil, don't turnResistance in the hips creates the coil.
Stable lead kneeIt can move, it can't collapse.
90 and 45Shoulders about 90, hips about half.
Turn throughLess over-turn back means more turn to the target.

Questions golfers ask

Should the lead knee move in the backswing?

A little, yes. It shouldn't collapse in, because then the hip collapses too and you lose your coil.

Why do I over-swing?

Often your lead knee and hip collapse, so your hips over-turn and the club keeps going.

Can a stable lead knee help if I get stuck?

Yes. Getting stuck often comes from not enough coil, then turning to the target too early. A good coil fixes both.

Not sure your knee is the cause?Tell Carolin what your ball does and get your personal fix. Free.
Find my miss
Read the full video transcript

Auto-captions, lightly edited for names and golf terms.

hi everybody and welcome to my golf hallway I'm Coach Carolin and today I want to talk to you about your left knee and I want to follow up on the real that I did last week which was a Hot Topic I mean my comment section was the place to be for a couple of days there so I figured I'd make a follow-up video in a long form to actually talk to you guys about it and discuss it because there was a lot of questions that came up there was some people that were wondering about it so I just want to make sure that we go through it step by step and I can explain why that video is actually so relevant to a lot of people swings more so than we think all right so the video that I'm referring to is called are you hitting your clubs all the same distance and the drill I was showing here in my hallway was essentially that I'm standing up next to this wall with my lead foot if you're Lefty would obviously be the other foot and then as I'm turning back I want to feel like this knee starts pushing towards this wall in my back swing and a lot of people came after me in my comment section saying oh it really needs to come in and there should be some shift in the left knee and guys there definitely should be a little bit of movement in that front knee and there will be a little bit of movement but this is a drill right we're here and we all know if we've played golf for a little bit of time or a long time that we have to exaggerate in the golf swing and drills by Nature do that right because as soon as we try to take it into the golf swing we're going to go back to very closely to where we were and feeling real are not the same thing and they're usually very far apart so I really like this because I want you to activate this muscle to actually push towards that wall and then as we're rotating yes my knee is going to move a little bit away from the wall but it is never going to just collapse in because what the collapse does and that is really devastating to a lot of people's golf swings the collapse of that left or lead knee makes that hip collapse and when the hip collapses we're not coiled anymore we're just turned you see how I'm facing like my body is fully facing this wall even my hips and my shoulders are fully facing this wall so happens now I have too much turn in my back swing and I'm likely overswinging and I'm also likely way too shallow in my shoulder plane so this is a steep shoulder plane or steeper this is more steep this is shallow a straight like parallel to the ground so as this breakdown happens a lot of people turn too shallow have too long of a swing and now the problem is that they've turned so much in the back swing they are going to not turn in the through swing so you've turned so far away from the Target that now turning back to the Target is going to be really hard so first you got to get the club from wherever it is likely over swung back up and around so you're starting to cast the club you're likely starting to throw it down and then your hands are coming down because you had to kind of throw it from this overturn and over swing into the down swing at the ball which we obviously don't want to do and then what happens your body because your hands are now overtaking your body your body has to stop and stall and that's when we see people a lot of amateures not having enough turn at impact so it kind of looks like they're pretty much square at impact or just a little open where really you should already be turned towards the target with your hips and your shoulders should be just a little almost parallel if and a little open at impact depending on the player but where we should not be as closed at the target with our body or parallel with our hips and shoulders so too much back turn too much of the wrong turn back is going to limit your turn towards the Target and really we want to go towards the Target right we want to make sure that we coil in our back swing not turn so now if we're feeling this if we're feeling like we're going to push our knee towards that left wall we're going to be able to coil because it's going to actually restrict our hip movement in a correct way so now my hips if you look at this I have almost a 45 degree turn that's what we want right we want our shoulders 90 and we want our hips half of that we don't want our hips 90 and our shoulders 90 or more so that is where this knee and the activation of physically pushing this way really helps so when we coiling correct ly we're resisting correctly we have a good turn we're not overturning it allows us to keep our shoulder plane steeper see how my shoulder plane isn't like this now it's actually turned down my left shoulder is under my chin and now we can actually start transitioning correctly and turning towards the target so the correct amount of back coil is going to allow us to actually turn much better towards the Target and our hands are going to be trailing our body in the correct way we're not going to be stuck behind right same thing applies if you're somebody who who actually is stuck behind and you feel like you're stuck in your back swing and your down swing especially what happens is you don't turn enough with your body that's the Other Extreme right you're if like if we're just exaggerate here and we're just not turning at all and then we start turning forward to the Target too soon because there really wasn't any back Co any back turn or back coil then we're stuck behind that's why a really good coil having that feeling of my our left leg being very stable and coiling around it my left knee comes forward a little bit it feels like it's pushing towards the Target and yes it's going to move in slightly and then we can actually correctly fire towards the Target and that is why this left knee is so key for a lot of players because it actually allows you to create coil not turn in the back swing so I hope you guys enjoyed this little video if this is your first time on my Channel please like subscribe and leave me a comment below I always love to hear from my followers and I can't wait to see you in my next hallway session w [Music]
Coach Carolin Pinegger
Coach Carolin (Carolin Pinegger)

Former tour player, Leadbetter Certified Instructor, GolfPass instructor, Golf Channel's Big Break. Millions of golfers follow Coach Carolin's lessons.

More on backswing and transition

This page gives you one drill. The Club gives you the plan.

  • Every current course, plus every new one
  • Start with Q-School, your guided first 30 days
  • A new training plan every month
  • A new challenge every month
  • Swing Review Live: Carolin reviews members' swings and answers your questions
  • Every live lesson replay
  • Priority access to Carolin and her team
  • 10% off golf schools and in-person lessons
Join the club30-day money-back guarantee. If it doesn't make your game better, contact us within 30 days and we refund every dollar.

Just want to fix this one thing?

Pure Contact: Hit Your Irons Solid, Every Time. The ball-first strike, step by step. The Strike Test to check your contact. The Iron Miss Fixer for the days it goes wrong.

Get Pure Contact
Pure ContactHit Your Irons Solid, Every Time
Get the course